RESERVATION -A problem for the deserving

Message
Author
hritikimtn
Posts: 6
Joined: Sat Nov 22, 2014 9:55 am

Re: RESERVATION -A problem for the deserving

#1 Postby hritikimtn » Mon Nov 24, 2014 1:06 am

Reservation is the biggest enemy for a general category person. Government should have to stop providing the reservations. It is unnecessary waste of our youth talent. Initially reservation was provided to the lower category of our society so that they could progress and uplift themselves equivalent to general category. But now this is becoming the biggest threat for general category people. Almost these all caste got progress today but still government are giving reservation to these castes. And not only reservations in various institutes and government jobs but also these castes are providing heavily subsidies for doing business which is also not a very good thing. If government is really wanted to give reservation then it should be on the basis of financial status not on the basis of caste.

vitaj
Posts: 60
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2014 9:50 pm

Re: RESERVATION -A problem for the deserving

#2 Postby vitaj » Sat Jul 26, 2014 10:38 am

Definitely, reservation is definitely a problem in India. You get admission in any college not because of merit but because of you belong to a certain caste. An example would be Common Aptitude Test-CAT which around 200000 students take every year. In year 2014, when result war declared, it a was seen that a student who has not attempted any question and got 0 marks got a zero percentile. The surprising thing is that he has got a call from IIM only because he belongs to a category. A student of general category who got 96% did not get a call but a student of category does.

pushkarp89
Posts: 38
Joined: Fri Jul 04, 2014 12:57 pm

Re: RESERVATION -A problem for the deserving

#3 Postby pushkarp89 » Wed Jul 16, 2014 6:00 pm

As far as my knowledge is concerned only BITS pilani do not follow any reservation quota procedure,it takes admissions for B.TECH only on the basis of capability and knowledge and thats why it is among the top leading institution of India even better than some IITs. It has maintain its quality of education over the years. It also provides 100% scholarships for those who has good academics scores rather than in which family you are born,which i think is the best thing.

ISTTMVINAY457
Posts: 107
Joined: Mon Apr 28, 2014 7:54 pm

Re: RESERVATION -A problem for the deserving

#4 Postby ISTTMVINAY457 » Wed Jul 16, 2014 1:47 pm

Reservations is a good thing. But not for all. It should be apply to the people who are economically weak and for handicapped persons. But our Indian government made it as hell for so many people. If you observe IIT and IIM , top most university's are filling their seats with reservation quota. Government has given chance to do that. But this is not right. The people who got better rank than reservation candidate, they are unable get it into university's. Our great politicians will say in the meeting like, we have lot of young power, we need to build young powerful India. But when these things will happen. If they continue the same reservation for the next coming generation, then our India would be "developing country " only. If they want build strong nation, remove this reservation system and provide it tho tribal people and uneducated people and encourage them. Even most of the PSU's will the jobs with reservation method, why don't encourage the people who really have lot of stuff. Most of the forward cast young stars are struggling like any thing. This is not the right way to lead the India. Even no one is fighting against India. One more important point, most of the autonomous university are filling their seats with merit base. We should feel shame about this, they are getting better results than IIT's and IIM's. They are providing better education to merit students.

saketroy2
Posts: 175
Joined: Mon May 26, 2014 11:23 am

Re: RESERVATION -A problem for the deserving

#5 Postby saketroy2 » Wed Jul 16, 2014 9:24 am

Reservation is not a bad thing...its base idea is to uplift the backwards. But our Government is using as a tool to be in power. Reservation should be given only to whose who are economically backward..not on caste, religion or anything else for that matters.

Whom do you count as talented? Those number of students who have crossed initial cut off or by comparing to others....there should be criteria for allocating seats too like...students below this mark can not be admitted....it will ruin the quality.

If the reservation would have been implemented properly...it would have been finished by now...

ISTTMpooja326
Posts: 109
Joined: Fri May 02, 2014 6:46 pm

Re: RESERVATION -A problem for the deserving

#6 Postby ISTTMpooja326 » Mon Jul 14, 2014 8:13 am

Yes, reservation is a big problem for the talented students.
According to Indian constitution the reservation should be provided only upto 20 years from the independance but its almost
more than 60 years and the reservation category still enjoying the reservation.
Even in government exam for admission or for job they have more preference than the talented people.
Unreserved students practice and work hard for this and he gains more than the reserved on but the unreserved will get admission
into small college and the reserved category in big collegeloped ce.
If this is the situation and it still continues then India will never become a developed country.
All the talented students are ignore.
I just want to give example of recent IIT main examination selection of qualified students.
Gen or oc students are qualified id they secure 110 marks in the examination, OBC students Should secure 74 and SC or ST students
should secure just 40(approx) to qualify the iit main.
Great, but true, So according to India government the students who secured 40(approx) are more talented than the students who
secured 110 and 74, then my question is to why they are organizing this stupid examination waste of time they directly can provide all
seats to the reserved students and even jobs.

pushkarp89
Posts: 38
Joined: Fri Jul 04, 2014 12:57 pm

RESERVATION -A problem for the deserving

#7 Postby pushkarp89 » Sat Jul 12, 2014 2:59 pm

From the last fifty years our politicians became very mature and understood that the reserved class of people could be a great vote-bank for any political party. So they took advantage of it by implementing certain laws on reservation.Earlier it was said that reservation is only aimed at at the upliftment of the lower section of the society. Now reservation was no longer an effort to uplift the depressed classes but it became a weapon of the politicians to carry on their vote-banks.
The reservation of seats in job crossed the limit set by the Supreme Court which does not recommend it beyond 50% of the total seat.
This policy has been implemented even in the AIIMS, IITs, and IIMs . Now these leading institutes will have seats reserved for the most undeserving candidates who are in no way capable of doing the job and thus decreasing the quality of education of these institutions.
One thing is very much clear they are in no-thinking for the sake of future generation because the quality of education will certainly fall in the high-class institutions like IIMs, IITs and AIIMS.As according to the professor of the IIT Kanpur with the increase of reservation quotas there is a gradual increase in the number of backs in various subjects of the student. And it is very clear from the fact that the quality of education is going down day by day.
Reservation not only effect the reputations of these institutes but also give discouragement to those students who are eligible but do not get selected. Now no one can ever think of the feelings of those students who really work hard yet being rejected.
The rich can go to the universities abroad but what will happen to the middle class students. No one can answer it.
If the government is really thinking of their upliftment then an alternative is also there,that they should give complete compensation of the fee of that coarse but reservation at the stake of degrading the quality of education is not a good solution for this.This system not only effects the quality of education but also led to the division of the society between general and reserved category students.


Return to “Marketing Management”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests